Saturday 4 May 2019

Local elections: reading the runes.





It is a truism that not a great deal can be predicted from local election results.  After all, only a third of  those  entitled actually vote, and  even in these grim times (turnout was only 66% in the 2015 general election, and 69% in 2017) we can expect around twice as many to vote in the next general election, whenever it comes.
Be that as it may, lessons are being drawn , so I may as well join in.

The Tories lost 1 334 seats.  Given that forecasts of losses in the region of 1 000 were regarded  as spin so that, when the actual losses were less, that could be sold as "not al that bad" -  to lose nearly a third more is pretty grim.

Labour lost "only" 82 seats.  But, after nine years of Tory rule, we should normally expect the main opposition party to be making huge gains, even if the government were reasonably competent, which the present one  patently isn't.

By contrast we Liberal Democrats gained 703 seats, considerably more than the 411 we lost when these seats were last fought in 2015,and more than the 500 "predicted" by the Tories  reasons of spin as above. And the Greens gained 194 seats.*

Astonishingly, both Labour and Conservative spokespersons interpret the result as instructions to "get on" with Brexit, by which they seem to mean complete it, however damaging the result may be, rather than abandon it.

Surely this is bizarre: given that the parties which made gains are we Liberal Democrats, openly and enthusiastically in favour of remaining in the EU, and the Greens too though their position is more masked.

 Surely the message could more sensibly be read that Brexit be abandoned.

Having said that, we don't actually know what  the half of the electorate who didn't vote in these elections actually think. Nor is it sensible to assume that all those who voted Liberal Democrat of Green actually agree with (or even know about) our pro-Remain stance.

And, of course there are local factors.  In the ward where I campaigned  we won 65% of the votes, but at least one voter told me openly hat his vote was "for local" and that he, as a "Veteran" was for Brexit as he  wouldn't want to fight for the Europeans.  (He didn't seem impressed by my rejoinder that at least if we fought  for a cause approved by the EU we should have had a say, whereas we didn't have much say when coat-tailing the Americans.)

One thing that stood out for me in observing the counting of the votes was the vastly increased number of spoiled papers, any with "we want Brexit" or similar (sometimes not very polite) messages scrawled on them.  There is clearly a great deal of anger amongst those who want Brexit  regardless of, or indifferent to, the consequences.  But I suspect this anger is confined to a relatively small minority, (see here for an analysis of this) and we should be careful not to allow those who shout loudest, either in parliament or among the grass roots, to call the tune.

We can, I think, conclude for these results that Labour's stance of "sitting on the fence" re Europe is gaining no traction with the electorate,  and these results will probably diminish their enthusiasm for a general election,  which would most probably result in another parliament without a majority, and in which  they would be unlikely to be the largest party.

Nor will cries by disaffected Tories that Mrs May should be replaced make much difference.  Brexit will still remain unsolvable.

So we remain where we started.  Either MPs pluck up the courage to Revoke Article 50 without further ado (in my view the best solution) or we put it to the electorate again in a People's Vote.

I think the Greens  were fortunate to do so well.  The recent publicity about climate change, arising from the TV programmes by David Attenborough, and the campaigning of  of the young Swedish girl, the remarkable Greta Thunbeerg, pushed the green cause to the forefront at just the right moment for them

3 comments:

  1. While I agree with most of your post, your last paragraph and the comment "I think the Greens were fortunate to do so well" worry me a lot - in particular because you haven't mentioned the other winners in May, the Independents.

    This time the Independents (and other minor parties) gained over 600 seats, nearly as many as we did, and we ignore this at our party's peril. When you incorporate that fact into the equation, you see a clear collapse of the major parties' share of the vote, with it moving to whichever other party/candidate people see as having a chance. What it does not show is a massive vindication of the Lib Dems alone. Thus the change has been driven by negatives on the big two than simply positive for the Lib Dems.

    However, just as the mainstream media have taken the Euro election results as a massive vindication of the Brexit Party, all the senior figures in our party (and those key influencers like LDV) are portraying this as a key breakthrough for the Lib Dems. As a result, more of the same, mainly hard work by the infantry, remains the only order of the day. I on the other hand look on it as a wonderful opportunity which we must do everything we can to consolidate and build on, and while yet more hard work by the troops will be essential, those at the top also need to do much, much more.

    We have to accept that Brexit as an issue will steadily diminish in the public's perceptions once it is decided (one way or the other) and the tide will steadily turn back towards those parties that people have instinctively relied on to fight their corner over the years, unless the whole party do something about it. Those who think that Brexit will continue as a major issue in the public consciousness if we leave, simply because Trade deals etc etc will keep it in the public eye are fooling themselves and fellow Lib Dems. The simple fact is that to the vast majority of the Public "Brexit does mean Brexit" and what comes after it will be a totally separate issue, an issue the Lib Dems do not have any history in (as far as the general public are concerned) and so we will once again be starting from well behind the other parties.

    This is where the leadership, all those senior figures, and those key influencers like LDV etc, will need to change and improve their game rapidly and I don't see any willingness or even acknowledgement in these groups to do so. So far the message from the top has simply been "Aren't we doing well again." However, to consolidate those votes that have come to us and develop, we need to clearly draw a line on those negative issues that dragged us down from coalition, which led to us flatlining right up to early this year, and not just continue to hope people will eventually forget. Indeed the number of times my posts on this matter get suppressed on other websites shows an unwillingness to even allow ordinary Lib Dems to embarrass their betters by debating these concerns.

    We have a lot to do – Peterborough is next, and we have to start planning right now.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello Guys!! I am Belinda. I live in Chicago  USA. I am very excited today and do not know where to start my testimony from. I was a poor woman with 3 kids and find it difficult to pay my bills and feed my kids.My husband left me and the kids for another woman and ever since then we were living in pain and hunger but just few days ago i came across a testimony of a man who got a blank ATM card from Mr.Alexander so i immediately contacted him for the same type of ATM card and i am very happy to announce to the world that i am living a fulfilled life. This blank ATM card can withdraw up to 10,000 dollars and more daily without you having any account with any bank. I have been able to buy a house and start my own business with this blank ATM card. Are you poor and need help then contact him now. Mr.Alexander email address is alexanderhackers01@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello Guys!! I am Caro. I live in Ohio, USA. I am very excited today and do not know where to start my testimony from. I was a poor woman with 3 kids and found it difficult to pay my bills and feed my kids. My husband left me and the kids for another woman and ever since then we were living in pain and hunger but just few days ago I came across a testimony of a man who got a blank ATM card from Mr. Alexander so I immediately contacted him for the same type of ATM card and i am very happy to announce to the world that I am living a fulfilled life. This blank ATM card can withdraw up to 10,000 dollars and more daily without you having any account with any bank. Now I have money for business, shopping and enough money for me and my family to live on. The card works in all countries and  that  is  the good news. Alexander email address is alexanderhackers01@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete