Wednesday, 28 August 2019
Prorogation: no holds barred
It's almost half a century since I taught what was then rather grandly called "British Constitution," but I remember at leat one of the standard textbooks (possibly Wade and Phillips Constitutional Law) explaining that parliament was solemnly prorogued, normally in the autumn of the year, and then solemnly opened again a day or two after.
From time immemorial these procedures normally took place in early November, which is why we have Bonfire Night on November 5th. (That was the date in 1605 when King, Lords and Commons all met in the same place at the same time for the "Opening of Parliament," so Guy Fawkes, had he succeeded, would have got rid of the entire political establishment in one go.)
So Mr Johnson's excuses for suspending parliament for several weeks are contrary to convention and flimsy in the extreme. This is clearly an attempt to prevent our legally and democratically appointed representatives exercising their functions at a time of great political crisis.
I am not as familiar as I'd like to be with the histories of other countries but understand that it is not unusual for megalomaniacs , often generals and suchlike, who think they have populist support, to overturn the normal political institutions, with their built in checks and balances,to implement their own intentions which they dress up as the popular will.
Johnson has not gone so far as to overturn our democratic institutions of ever (yet), but to suspend them at this critical time shows outrageous arrogance. Let's hope he and his cohort now in No 10 have overstepped the mark and get their comeuppance.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
It will take a lot more than hope. We all have to be up for a lot more than that and not just pretend that hope, optimism and being right is enough. That is just the starting point.
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely outrageous, and double standards of the democracy loving Brexiteers, who so adamantly stood by the democratic will of the people, but not so the democratic rule of parliament. So the Brexit story continues to unfold, with further testing of our constitutional law.
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely outrageous. Those that ardently support the democratic will of the people don't support the democratic will of parliament. Brexit continues to throw up lessons and challenges for our constitutional laws.
ReplyDeleteHe's only closing Parliament for three or four days more than it would normally be suspended for the party conferences… what exactly are the anti-democracy forces planning that they could have got done before but now can't because they have (gasp) a whole four less days to do it in?
ReplyDeleteSeveral weeks. I think I heard five on tonight's news. Certainly more than "a day or two."
DeleteAbout five weeks total, yes. But most of that time Parliament would have been suspended for the conferences anyway, as it is every September. The extra closure amounts to about three or four days.
DeleteWhat did the anti-democracy faction have planned that they now don't have time for? Or are they just cross that they now have to make some decisions quickly and don't have the time they were counting on spending faffing about not coming up with any concrete plan, which is all they've been doing up to now?