Sunday 26 December 2021

Freedom... For whom? To do what?

 

"Deregulation is a euphemism  for destroying the capacity of the state to protect us from chancers, conmen and criminals."

So writes George Monbiot in and article in the Guardian, 24/12/2021. 

 A hundred  Conservative MPs, under the pretext of libertarianism, have opposed their own government over the matter of regulation to protect us all from  the dangers of COVID pandemic.   Now that the scientists suspect that, if we catch the new Omicron variant, we are 40% les likely to land in hospital than if we catch the Delta variant, supporters of the 100 applaud their "chief chancer" for "getting it right" and avoiding a second Christmas lockdown. 

 Personally I prefer to take the advice of the medical establishment, which urges us to show restraint and avoid all contact which isn't absolutely all that important to us.

I find it bizarre that Conservative MPs on the right of their party (which seems to be most of them) dare to campaign under the banner of liberty and freedom, issues on which the Tory party and its predecessors have not, historically, been all that keen. The liberties of Roman Catholics to practise their religion in their own way, of non-conformists to attend universities and enter the professions, were never high on their agenda. I suspect that the liberty of Jews to participate in activities was more commonly restricted  in Tory patronised golf clubs than in any other area of society (and that includes today's Labour Party). 

More recently Conservatives have not been enthusiastic about the freedom of Gays to live their preferred lifestyles (the notorious Section 28 of Mrs thatcher's Local Government Act 1988, banned the "promotion" of homosexuality by local authorities and in Britain's schools);  nor the rights of Gypsies and Travellers  to live according to their traditions; the present Home Secretary doesn't seem too keen on protect the freedom of young people, particularly youngsters of colour, to walk our street;  and the liberty of desperate asylum seekers and migrants to reach our shores safely and place their talents and energies at our disposal seems non-existent. 

So whose liberties do the Tories cherish?  Essentially those of the Have lots" to exploit the "have less" and to preserve their advantages from generation to generation..

Preserving and extending Liberty is the underlying purpose of the Liberal Democrat Party.  Liberalism is aptly  defined in an earlier Guardian article by Timothy Garton Ash as: "a quest  for the greatest possible  measure of individual human freedom compatible with the freedom of others." The key phrase is "compatible with the freedom of others."

Migrants coming to our shores do not hamper my freedom, they enhance it.  Youths behaving normally in the street are totally compatible with my freedom (though I'm not so sure I can say the same for dog owners who allow their pets to harass me - only being friendly - as I jog round our country park).

On the other hand people who fail to get vaccinated without good cause, or refuse to wear face-masks in enclosed areas, do limit my freedom, both by putting my heath at risk and maybe cluttering up the hospitals unnecessarily  should I need treatment.

 As R H Tawney famously points out in his celebrated "Equality" (1931): freedom for the pike is death to the minnows.

Tory MPs, especially those representing the "red wall" seats, should consider carefully whose freedoms they are protecting, and how they are likely to exercise them.


4 comments:

  1. On the other hand people who fail to get vaccinated without good cause, or refuse to wear face-masks in enclosed areas, do limit my freedom, both by putting my heath at risk and maybe cluttering up the hospitals unnecessarily should I need treatment.

    You know, I can just imagine you in another time and place:

    'On the other hand, kulaks who refuse to join the collectivisation effort do limit my freedom, both by standing in the way of the necessary reforms to bring about the progressive society of the future and by hoarding grain that so the rest of us have to starve!'

    ReplyDelete
  2. As always thanks for your comment. I wasn't there then but I am here now and do not want my health to be compromised by people who, without reasonable grounds, refuse to take precautions.

    I recognise the validity of your point though: it's a matter of "Where to draw the line." Presumably you would not object to people's freedom being limited to driving on only one side of the road? But driving without a seatbelt? A lot of "libertarians" made a fuss about that, but it's now generally accepted. Smoking in indoor public places, especially pubs. Ditto. Pedestrians crossing the road at places other than designated crossings. Illegal in some countries but not there.

    When asked about vaccination the Archbishop; of Canterbury gave what I thought was a good answer: no compulsion, but Jesus taught "Love thy neighbour" and wearing a mask and being vaccinated is an example of this love. QED?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Presumably you would not object to people's freedom being limited to driving on only one side of the road?

    No indeed, if people want to drive.

    But driving without a seatbelt?

    No strong feelings either way. If someone proposed abolishing the mandatory seatbelt laws, I wouldn't object.

    Smoking in indoor public places, especially pubs.

    I'm not keen on the smoking ban, and wasn't at the time. As long as I personally can find a pub where I can sit without having to breathe stinking smoke, I don't mind if other people do want to slowly kill themselves. That's up to them.

    Pedestrians crossing the road at places other than designated crossings. Illegal in some countries but not there.

    And thank goodness we are sensible, and don't make people into criminals just because they cross the road unwisely.

    When asked about vaccination the Archbishop; of Canterbury gave what I thought was a good answer: no compulsion, but Jesus taught "Love thy neighbour" and wearing a mask and being vaccinated is an example of this love. QED?

    I don't agree with him, no, but I don't feel like arguing as long as he is clear on the important point, that there should be no compulsion.

    Out of interest: would you agree that it is fundamentally important for a free society that the individual should always be free to do anything which is not specifically prohibited by law (as opposed to the alternative view, that individuals should be free to do anything which the government specifically allows, in accordance with the laws by which the activity is regulated — which is a managed, not a free, society)?

    And do you agree that it is an essential part of a free society that, for example, we in the United Kingdom are free to start any kind of private club, whether that be a sports club, a reading club, a debating society, or any other kind of association, without having to notify the authorities or register with them? and that countries where that is not true, where private clubs have to be registered with the authorities in order to be able to have, for example, bank accounts (such as, say, France), are significantly and importantly less free, and it is important that we are constantly on our guard against sliding into that kind of situation?

    ReplyDelete
  4. LEGIT FULLZ & TOOLS STORE

    Hello to All !

    We are offering all types of tools & Fullz on discounted price.
    If you are in search of anything regarding fullz, tools, tutorials, Hack Pack, etc
    Feel Free to contact

    ***CONTACT 24/7***
    **Telegram > @leadsupplier
    **ICQ > 752822040
    **Skype > Peeterhacks
    **Wicker me > peeterhacks

    "SSN LEADS/FULLZ AVAILABLE"
    "TOOLS & TUTORIALS AVAILABLE FOR HACKING, SPAMMING,
    CARDING, CASHOUT, CLONING, SCRIPTING ETC"

    **************************************
    "Fresh Spammed SSN Fullz info included"
    >>SSN FULLZ with complete info
    >>CC With CVV (vbv & non vbv) Fullz USA
    >>FULLZ FOR SBA, PUA & TAX RETURN FILLING
    >>USA I.D Photos Front & Back
    >>High Credit Score fullz (700+ Scores)
    >>DL number, Employee Details, Bank Details Included
    >>Complete Premium Info with Relative Info

    ***************************************
    COMPLETE GUIDE FOR TUTORIALS & TOOLS

    "SPAMMING" "HACKING" "CARDING" "CASH OUT"
    "KALI LINUX" "BLOCKCHAIN BLUE PRINTS" "SCRIPTING"
    "FRAUD BIBLE"

    "TOOLS & TUTORIALS LIST"
    =>Ethical Hacking Ebooks, Tools & Tutorials
    =>Bitcoin Hacking
    =>Kali Linux
    =>Fraud Bible
    =>RAT
    =>Keylogger & Keystroke Logger
    =>WhatsApp Hacking & Hacked Version of WhatsApp
    =>Facebook & Google Hacking
    =>Bitcoin Flasher
    =>SQL Injector
    =>Premium Logs (PayPal/Amazon/Coinbase/Netflix/FedEx/Banks)
    =>Bitcoin Cracker
    =>SMTP Linux Root
    =>Shell Scripting
    =>DUMPS with pins track 1 and 2 with & without pin
    =>SMTP's, Safe Socks, Rdp's brute
    =>PHP mailer
    =>SMS Sender & Email Blaster
    =>Cpanel
    =>Server I.P's & Proxies
    =>Viruses & VPN's
    =>HQ Email Combo (Gmail, Yahoo, Hotmail, MSN, AOL, etc.)

    *Serious buyers will always welcome
    *Price will be reduce in bulk order
    *Discount offers will give to serious buyers
    *Hope we do a great business together

    ===>Contact 24/7<===
    ==>Telegram > @leadsupplier
    ==>ICQ > 752822040
    ==>Skype > Peeterhacks
    ==>Wicker me > peeterhacks

    ReplyDelete