I have long believed that the annual Budget is over-hyped on the UK.
Up to the middle of the last century some MPs would wear top hats and morning suites in the House of Commons of Budget Day in order to "recognise" its importance. Today we are bombarded for weeks before it with speculation on what might be in it, then for a couple of days the media concentrate on how various sections of the population are affected.
After that, save for some monumental bloomers (Liz Truss) or foolish errors ( the Starmer government's decision to increase the tax on employment) its contents are forgotten
I believe this alleged importance is misguided for two reasons.
First the decisions very rarely affect the quality of life of the majority of the people. For example, the headline item of this budget was an extra £100 for more modest households (including mine) to help with fuel bills. Even for the very poorest household that it hardly likely to be life-changing, It amounts to £2 per week and the purchasing power of a £1 today is barely more than that of a threpenny-bit of my youth (and looks much the same)
Secondly, the fuss over-estimates the importance of income on the quality of our lives. Once our incomes are sufficient to have "enough," then more has little consequence. And 80% of us in the UK, maybe even 90% have enough. Beyond that relationships, leisure pursuits, creative arts, sports and culture, have far more impact..
Gandhi pointed out that "The World has enough for everyone's need, but not for everyone's greed."
If that's true for the World then it's certainly true for the UK, still in the top ten of richest economies.
That is not to say that the various minor tweaks in Mr Healey's budget - increase in the gambling tax on slot machines, more revenue to be spent locally (though I would prefer through councils rather than Santa Claus mayors), end of standing charges for utilities - are not welcome.
But these are a far cry for the sweeping away of 40 years of neo-liberalism, nor any significant movement towards fairer taxation.
As Tax Justice UK comments:
There was no progress on a Wealth Tax. No serious reform of Capital Gains Tax. No equalisation of taxes on wealth and work. No meaningful reform of council tax. No windfall tax on excess bank profits. No substantial action on aggressive corporate tax avoidance. No commitment to bring failing privatised utilities back into public ownership.
And 80% of us in the UK, maybe even 90% have enough.
ReplyDeleteWho made you the judge of what is ‘enough’?
Beyond that relationships, leisure pursuits, creative arts, sports and culture, have far more impact..
You do realise that leisure pursuits, creative arts, sports and culture all cost money? Have you seen the prices of theatre or concert tickets these days? Sports equipment isn’t cheap either, and nor is sports hall hire. Not to mention art supplies!
For that matter even relationships cost money, unless you live within walking distance of each other: petrol, trains and aeroplanes aren’t free.
Enough for everyone's needs - and then some, for the overwhelming majority of us.
DeleteEnough for everyone's needs - and then some, for the overwhelming majority of us.
DeleteAnd who gets to define what I ‘need’? You? Who gave you that authority?
I notice you didn’t address the other point. Cultural activities. For example, cost money. I need to see a West End play every month, but I can’t afford that. Therefore I don’t have enough for my needs. Are you going to argue with me?
Well, "essentials" if you prefer that to "needs." As to culture, I agree that "a little bit of what you fancy does you good," so "something tasty," as Orwell pointed out, should be available to everyone form time to time.
DeleteWell, "essentials" if you prefer that to "needs."
DeleteBut hang on — every time I say that there's no real poverty in Britain today because everyone has enough for the essentials of life, you argue with me, citing statistics that say some huge proportion of the population is 'in poverty'.
Yet here you are saying that (almost) everyone in Britain can afford the essentials.
So which is it? Is it true that (nearly) everyone in Britain has enough for the essentials of life, in which case I am right and there is no need for redistributive taxation of the kind you favour? Or not?
See the second part of the above comment
DeleteSee the second part of the above comment
DeleteI don't see how that's relevant? Do you think that 90% of people in Britain have enough for the essentials (in which case you have to stop claiming that some huge number of millions of people are living in poverty in Britain) or do you not?
you can't just redefine 'essentials' as meaning essentials and some luxuries sometimes'. Essentials means essentials.
Budget was largely a non event. Perhaps deliberately so to buy time to consider how to tackle the 'wicked' problems the country faces
ReplyDeleteYes, the spin doctors claim it is to give the public a breathing space, but I suspect it really to give one to the government itself. That could be good tactics, to give themselves time to tackle the issues raised by Tax Justice UK and others preferably on an multi- party basis and utilising citizens' assemblies.
ReplyDeleteutilising citizens' assemblies
DeleteCitizens’ assemblies are unrepresentative and their proposals still have to pass the democratic test, which there is no guarantee that they will: see the recent referendum in the Irish Republic where an proposal endorsed strongly by a citizens’ assembly was overwhelmingly rejected by the actual population.
Here we go again
DeleteEvidence that citizens adsemblies are "unrepresentative" ?
And do enlighten us
DeleteWhat is the declared purpose of these (not your own "unrepresentative" opinion)?
Evidence that citizens adsemblies are "unrepresentative" ?
DeleteThey are a self-selecting sample. All self-selecting samples are unrepresentative.
As I thought you've no idea
DeleteCAs are NOT self selected
They're created on behalf of an organisation to be representative of a defined statistical population using scientific market research methodology
CAs are NOT self selected
DeleteYes they are. You can’t force someone to serve on a citizens’ assembly, so anyone selected to serve on one who doesn’t want to (for example, because they have a job) will opt out.
Therefore everyone who is on the citizens’ assembly has self-selected onto it (by not opting out).
Oh dear BS again
DeleteDo you actually understand the principles of sample selection?
Redundant question - you clearly don't
Do you actually understand the principles of sample selection?
DeleteI do. Do you? You should read:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-selection_bias
And
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Participation_bias
Bs
DeleteIt's not self selection
Try reading the chapter in one of my books or equivalent on sample selection methods that ensure representative sampling
You've really no idea as to how CAs are set up have you?
DeleteTry wiki again, it's not the most robust source but it's a start
You've really no idea as to how CAs are set up have you?
DeleteI do. They are formed from people who are willing to take part (so I, for example, am not represented because I would refuse to take part) and then the organisers carefully select the framing of the questions they are asked to consider, and what evidence they are given, and who speaks to them, in order to get them to come to the conclusion that the organisers want them to.
If they are so representative, how come the one in the Irish Republic unanimously proposed a constitutional amendment that turned out to be incredibly unpopular when put to the population?
All you're doing is showing your own ignorance here.
DeleteTopic area chosen
Statistical population is defined
Stratified random sampling selects participants
Learning, deliberation, recommendation approach applied and supported
Stratified random sampling selects participants
DeleteAnd then all the sensible participants (the ones who might represent me) self-select put because they have more important things to do, like work for a living, and are replaced (to make up the numbers) by more layabouts and activists, making the whole results totally unrepresentative.
Learning, deliberation, recommendation approach applied and supported
And carefully directed by the organisers, who select what questions are asked, and who chair the deliberations, to ensure that their desired recommendations are the result.
Then the results are put to the electorate and defeated.
Result: just a whole lot of wasted money.
When you've bothered to properly understand the methodology do get back in touch and you may be able to join in an adult conversation
DeleteI think I’ll just wait and use my vote.
DeleteBased on your usual ignorance then given you've not bothered to understand the methodology
DeleteI have confidence that the sensible majority (including me) will, at the ballot box, reject the nonsense proposals that come from these citizens' assemblies, as they did in the Irish Republic.
DeleteAs ever you simply display your ignorance
DeleteCA conclusions are not meant for the ballot box but for policy makers.
You're a great example of the old saying
When you find yourself in a hole - stop digging
CA conclusions are not meant for the ballot box but for policy makers.
DeleteOh, so you’re admitting that you know these policies would be unpopular with the electorate, so you want to bypass democratic scrutiny?
Fortunately there’s a solution to that: we will just elect a government that will repeal anything that came out of the citizens’ assemblies.
You really are clueless aren't you?
DeleteLet's look at Ireland that you keep banging on about.
Each CA ( you do know there's been more than one?) is randomly selected to be representative,,(and this is checked if you bother to look) and focusses on a given topic.
Any recommendations that emerge are strictly advisory and it's up to the politicians to decide how to respond
You're clearly unaware of this given it IS part of democratic scrutiny
Some recommendations have been incorporated directly into policy.
Others have been voted on directly with some leading to a change in policy/law others have been rejected
I call that democracy in action
Why don't you?
Any recommendations that emerge are strictly advisory and it's up to the politicians to decide how to respond
DeleteSo how is a citizen's assembly different from the normal democratic process, where lobby groups, think tanks, etc, make recommendations and it's up to politicians how to respond?
If citizens' assemblies are just an expensive way of coming up with the same recommendations that could equally well have been made by think tanks, then the whole citizens' assembly process is just a big waste of time and money.
So what's the point of them, if, as you say, they just make recommendations that politicians can consider in the same way as already happens?
Oh dear
DeleteI did suggest a while ago that you read up on this but you obviously haven't
So paying a think tank is ok but a CA isn't!!!
Clueless
Each CA ( you do know there's been more than one?) is randomly selected to be representative
DeleteIt can't possibly be representative if all the people of a certain kind (eg, those who have jobs) refuse to serve (eg, because they are too busy earning a living). That entire section of society (the sensible, productive sort) will be unrepresented.
So paying a think tank is ok but a CA isn't!!!
DeleteThink tanks are not paid with taxpayers' money.
I would have no problem with an entirely advisory citizens' assembly which was privately funded.
If people want to waste their money on glorified focus groups that's up to them.
I just object to either my tax money being spent on them, or on their recommendation being treated as if they are somehow representative of the population (because they are definitely not representative of me).
Oh dear, Clueless
DeletePlease read the methodology used by Ireland.
Think tanks are paid with taxpayer's money for specific research projects
Think tanks are paid with taxpayer's money for specific research projects
DeleteBut not for lobbying, and a citizens' assembly is not a specific research project -- it's lobbying.
And frankly I'd rather my tax money wasn't spent on think tank research projects either. It's a conflict of interest: a think tank which wants to continue to receive paid government contracts will be discouraged from criticising the government.
Lobbying???
DeleteYou really are clueless, Clueless
They're set up by a government
They're set up by a government
DeleteSo?
Anything which tries to get a government to adopt particular policies is lobbying. That's what lobbying is. Citizens' assemblies exist to try to get government to enact the policies they come up with. Therefore they are lobbying, just like think tanks are when they try to get governments to enact policies they come up with, or charities are when they try to get governments to enact policies they come up with.
How is it not lobbying? Why does being set up by a government make a difference?
Anyway the whole point is, it's set up by the government so it's funded by tax-payer's money. That means my money. I don't want my money wasted in that way. So I shall vote against any party which proposes to set up any citizens' assembly. I expect most sensible people agree with me and will vote likewise, so it will never happen.
Oh dear there's so much about the world you don't understand isn't there?
ReplyDeleteHow can a govt lobby itself?
How can a govt lobby itself?
DeleteIt's called 'policy laundering'.
Activists within a government have a policy they want enacted, but they know that it's not popular with the public.
So they set up a nominally 'independent' organisation, funded by the government, which then calls for that policy, puts out rigged polls saying that the policy is popular, etc etc, generating lots of media coverage.
The activists in government then say, 'Look! People are clamouring for this policy! We better do it!'
The idea is to convince members of the public who dislike the policy that the activists in government are simply responding to widespread demand in enacting this policy (even though the demand is not widespread at all, it's just the handful of government-funded lobby groups getting lots of media coverage), so that the members of the public don't blame them for the policy and stop voting for them.
It's a common practice.
Keep looking in that mirror
Delete