Thursday 21 February 2019

How not to break the mould


"Break the mould" was the slogan of the SDP/Liberal Alliance after the defection of 28  (yes 28) Labour MPs to form their Social Democratic Party (SDP) in 1981.  A sole Conservative joined them as well.  Together with by-election successes  (Roy Jenkins at Glasgow Hillhead, for example) and the existing 11 Liberal MPs the Alliance eventually totalled  around 40 MPs, but , in the first General Election to follow, in 1983, although our Alliance polled 25% of the vote (against Labour's 28%and the Tories' 42%) only 23 Alliance MPs were elected, just six of whom were members of the SDP.

The First Past the Post electoral system is a killer.

The reasons we failed to "break the mould" are many and varied, but I think  the main one is that only one of the bigger parties fractured.  The Tories held together.  Loyalty is their secret weapon.

When the Alliance was formed in the early 80s both major parties were hugely unpopular. Mrs Thatcher's economic policy of a  monetary and fiscal squeeze  caused unemployment to rise above 3 million and reduced the UK's manufacturing base by a fifth. Labour under Michael Foot were reputed to have a series of wildly left wing policies which included nuclear disarmament (good idea) and leaving the European Community (very bad idea, and still is).

However, the Tories recovered their popularity as a result of  of Mrs Thatcher's "successful" Falklands War, whereas the Labour party didn't until Tony Blair and Gordon Brown came along.to make them electable with  their  triangulation and "third way."

Consequently only half the "mould " was broken: there never were any significant Tory defections, either in parliament or a grass roots level.



So "two party politics " was effectively restored, although the growth of the Liberal Democrats (the merged SDP and Liberal parties) to 22% of the vote and  62 seats in 2005 and the Nationals in both Wales and Scotland dented things a bit (at least until 2015 when we Liberal Democrats  were back down to 8 % of the vote and only 11 MPs)

 It is good to see the two party system now crumbling at both its edges but I cannot see the present defectors being any more successful than we were in the 1980s, at least if they continue with with their present lack of either organisation or policies.  They seem to be evolving haphazardly rather than with a plan.

Their biggest mistake, in my view, so far at any rate, is to fail to resign their seats and fight by-elections.  This is perhaps wise on their part becasue they would undoubtedly lose, but their failure to face the music of their convictions  merely enhances public cynicism towards politicians.

In my view a better approach would have been:

1. To concentrate on one issue and one issue only, opposition to Brexit.

2. Not to resign from their parties, but to say that, regardless of party instructions, they would speak and vote to do all in their power to stop Brexit, either by voting to withdraw Article 50, (the best approach),or  to put any deal achieved to a People's Vote, with staying in the EU as the alternative (a messy second best.)

If their parities then chose to withdraw the Whips (ie expel them ) that would leave them on the moral high ground: they could claim that they were not in the wrong, but effectively and honestly fulfilling their duties in using their judgement for the good of the country.

This approach could have produced far more support from both sides.  maybe it still could.

If and when the Brexit issue is (even temporarily) settled, they could then go on to consider the future. Do they really have enough in common to form a new party, or should they switch the single issue and campaign for proportional representation by single transferable vote in multi-member constituencies, (the best idea, I think) or should the revert to their parties to try to obtain reform from within?


6 comments:

  1. I've been reluctant in purchasing this blank ATM card I heard about online because everything seems too good to be true,but I was convinced & shocked when my friend at my place of work got the card from ALEXANDERHACKERS & we both confirmed it really works,without delay I gave it a go. Ever since then I've been withdrawing about $5,500 daily from the card & the money has been in my own account. So glad I got my card it truly works and made me rich!! GOOD NEWS! the card works in all countries.If you need this card don't hesitate to contact Alexander's email address: alexanderhackers01@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  2. I've been reluctant in purchasing this blank ATM card I heard about online because everything seems too good to be true,but I was convinced & shocked when my friend at my place of work got the card from ALEXANDERHACKERS & we both confirmed it really works,without delay I gave it a go. Ever since then I've been withdrawing about $5,500 daily from the card & the money has been in my own account. So glad I got my card it truly works and made me rich!! GOOD NEWS! the card works in all countries.If you need this card don't hesitate to contact Alexander's email address: alexanderhackers01@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello Guys!! I am Belinda. I live in Chicago  USA. I am very excited today and do not know where to start my testimony from. I was a poor woman with 3 kids and find it difficult to pay my bills and feed my kids.My husband left me and the kids for another woman and ever since then we were living in pain and hunger but just few days ago i came across a testimony of a man who got a blank ATM card from Mr.Alexander so i immediately contacted him for the same type of ATM card and i am very happy to announce to the world that i am living a fulfilled life. This blank ATM card can withdraw up to 10,000 dollars and more daily without you having any account with any bank. I have been able to buy a house and start my own business with this blank ATM card. Are you poor and need help then contact him now. Mr.Alexander email address is alexanderhackers01@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello Guys!! I am Belinda. I live in Chicago  USA. I am very excited today and do not know where to start my testimony from. I was a poor woman with 3 kids and find it difficult to pay my bills and feed my kids.My husband left me and the kids for another woman and ever since then we were living in pain and hunger but just few days ago i came across a testimony of a man who got a blank ATM card from Mr.Alexander so i immediately contacted him for the same type of ATM card and i am very happy to announce to the world that i am living a fulfilled life. This blank ATM card can withdraw up to 10,000 dollars and more daily without you having any account with any bank. I have been able to buy a house and start my own business with this blank ATM card. Are you poor and need help then contact him now. Mr.Alexander email address is alexanderhackers01@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hello Guys!! I am Caro. I live in Ohio, USA. I am very excited today and do not know where to start my testimony from. I was a poor woman with 3 kids and found it difficult to pay my bills and feed my kids. My husband left me and the kids for another woman and ever since then we were living in pain and hunger but just few days ago I came across a testimony of a man who got a blank ATM card from Mr. Alexander so I immediately contacted him for the same type of ATM card and i am very happy to announce to the world that I am living a fulfilled life. This blank ATM card can withdraw up to 10,000 dollars and more daily without you having any account with any bank. Now I have money for business, shopping and enough money for me and my family to live on. The card works in all countries and  that  is  the good news. Alexander email address is alexanderhackers01@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hello Guys!! I am Caro. I live in Ohio, USA. I am very excited today and do not know where to start my testimony from. I was a poor woman with 3 kids and found it difficult to pay my bills and feed my kids. My husband left me and the kids for another woman and ever since then we were living in pain and hunger but just few days ago I came across a testimony of a man who got a blank ATM card from Mr. Alexander so I immediately contacted him for the same type of ATM card and i am very happy to announce to the world that I am living a fulfilled life. This blank ATM card can withdraw up to 10,000 dollars and more daily without you having any account with any bank. Now I have money for business, shopping and enough money for me and my family to live on. The card works in all countries and  that  is  the good news. Alexander email address is alexanderhackers01@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete