Tuesday 6 July 2021

More on the Batley and Spen Result.

Sadly comments on the result of our Batley and Spen by-election, even from the Labour Party, stress the narrowness of their win rather than the glaring failure of the Tories to take the seat, which they were widely predicted to do. 

Labour had two massive obstacles to overcome. First, the Conservative vote in 2019 was reduced by the presence on the ballot paper of a right wing so-called Heavy Woollen District candidate, Paul Halloran  who attracted 6 439 votes (12.2%).  When it was announced that  Halloran had decided (been persuaded?) not to stand in the by-election "progressive" hearts sank: without him to split their vote the Tories were almost bound to win.

Then in addition the maverick former Labour MP George Galloway entered the fray for the so called "Workers' Party, thus potentially  splitting the Labour vote.

Labour had not one but two obstacles to overcome, two mountains to climb.

In these circumstances it is astonishing that the Tories failed to take the seat.  That is what, in my view, should be in the headlines

In last Saturday's Guardian the normally perceptive  Jonathan Freedman claimed that "Batley and Spen  saw a 2.9% swing away from Labour  and towards the Conservatives, the largest swing to a govenmt party  in 39 years"  (My emphasis).  This, if technically correct, is highly misleading.

In fact their percentage share of the vote fell for both Labour (-7.4 percentage points) and Conservatives (-1.6).  This was presumably largely due to the presence of no less than 14 other candidates.  Interestingly the Conservatives do no seem to have benefited much  from Halloran's 6000+ votes.

The alleged 2.9% "Swing" is calculated by taking the difference between the two changes in share of the vote (7.4 - 1.6 = 5.8) and dividing it by 2 (=2.9 ). The impression that 2.9% of voters switched from Labour to Conservative may have made sense in the 1950s and the days of "two horse races" and Peter Snow's "swingometer." 

 It makes no sense in a multiparty contest in which increases and decreases in major parties' shares are likely  to be the result of shifts to other parties rather than direct swaps between the two major parties.

The real message  of the Batley and Spen by-election is a major Conservative  failure to win a contest weighted in their favour.  Together with the massive Liberal Democrat victory in Chesham and Amersham, it is another sign that Mr Johnson's Teflon carapace is not impregnable.

11 comments:

  1. Empires rise and fall Johnsons has been VERY damaging but the cracks are appearing

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. LEGIT FULLZ & TOOLS STORE

      Hello to All !

      We are offering all types of tools & Fullz on discounted price.
      If you are in search of anything regarding fullz, tools, tutorials, Hack Pack, etc
      Feel Free to contact

      ***CONTACT 24/7***
      **Telegram > @leadsupplier
      **ICQ > 752822040
      **Skype > Peeterhacks
      **Wicker me > peeterhacks

      "SSN LEADS/FULLZ AVAILABLE"
      "TOOLS & TUTORIALS AVAILABLE FOR HACKING, SPAMMING,
      CARDING, CASHOUT, CLONING, SCRIPTING ETC"

      **************************************
      "Fresh Spammed SSN Fullz info included"
      >>SSN FULLZ with complete info
      >>CC With CVV (vbv & non vbv) Fullz USA
      >>FULLZ FOR SBA, PUA & TAX RETURN FILLING
      >>USA I.D Photos Front & Back
      >>High Credit Score fullz (700+ Scores)
      >>DL number, Employee Details, Bank Details Included
      >>Complete Premium Info with Relative Info

      ***************************************
      COMPLETE GUIDE FOR TUTORIALS & TOOLS

      "SPAMMING" "HACKING" "CARDING" "CASH OUT"
      "KALI LINUX" "BLOCKCHAIN BLUE PRINTS" "SCRIPTING"
      "FRAUD BIBLE"

      "TOOLS & TUTORIALS LIST"
      =>Ethical Hacking Ebooks, Tools & Tutorials
      =>Bitcoin Hacking
      =>Kali Linux
      =>Fraud Bible
      =>RAT
      =>Keylogger & Keystroke Logger
      =>WhatsApp Hacking & Hacked Version of WhatsApp
      =>Facebook & Google Hacking
      =>Bitcoin Flasher
      =>SQL Injector
      =>Premium Logs (PayPal/Amazon/Coinbase/Netflix/FedEx/Banks)
      =>Bitcoin Cracker
      =>SMTP Linux Root
      =>Shell Scripting
      =>DUMPS with pins track 1 and 2 with & without pin
      =>SMTP's, Safe Socks, Rdp's brute
      =>PHP mailer
      =>SMS Sender & Email Blaster
      =>Cpanel
      =>Server I.P's & Proxies
      =>Viruses & VPN's
      =>HQ Email Combo (Gmail, Yahoo, Hotmail, MSN, AOL, etc.)

      *Serious buyers will always welcome
      *Price will be reduce in bulk order
      *Discount offers will give to serious buyers
      *Hope we do a great business together

      ===>Contact 24/7<===
      ==>Telegram > @leadsupplier
      ==>ICQ > 752822040
      ==>Skype > Peeterhacks
      ==>Wicker me > peeterhacks

      Delete
  2. The essential truth of the matter is that 'It was Kim and the Leadbeater family wot won it'. Enough good decent people cared enough to vote for her as a good decent person - someone who cares and loves her home area to do this..... whilst possibly Hancock did enough to squeeze out the 300 plus extra votes Kim needed.

    People were more important than parties.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comment, David. I gathered from LDV that you know the family. I was canvassed by Kim herself and was very impressed. She certainly has a mind of her own and will bat hard on behalf of the area. I'm not sure that's all we want in an MP, though. More of that later.

      Delete
  3. In these circumstances it is astonishing that the Tories failed to take the seat.

    I don't think that a government failing to win a by-election off the opposition can ever be described as 'astonishing'. How many such cases have there been in the past seventy years? Half a dozen?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Agreed it doesn't happen often, but in this case the Conservatives missed a wide open goal.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not by much (under 350 votes).

      If I were Labour I wouldn't be seeing this as a sign that victory is now within their grasp.

      (Similarly if I were the Conservatives I would be seeing this as a sign that they can't assume their victory is inevitable).

      Delete
    2. Agreed, there's still a lot to play for, except that it is not about a "play" either on a stage of a field, but a serious matter affecting the lives of millions (eg the failure to maintain the extra £20 on Universal Credit, or the manifesto promise to maintain the overseas aid at 0.7% of GDP.) Politics is not a game, or a TV popularity contest but increasingly we treat it as such

      Delete
    3. Politics is not a game, or a TV popularity contest but increasingly we treat it as such

      Though that's not half so bad as implying that people are dumb or gullible for the way they vote, rather than accepting that they understand perfectly what they are voting for and just disagree with you. Like, say, accusing the voters of Hartlepool of having Stockholm syndrome.

      (whenever anybody does it on any side — it's mostly lefties who are condescending about people who vote against them at the moment, but the right has certainly been guilty of it in its time)

      Delete
  5. I had to look up "Stockholm syndrome." I'm not sure how it works for the right. I can see how "lefties" fall for their oppressors (eg Macdonald was very fond of duchesses, or so I've read, and I'm presently hooked on repeats of Downton Abbey -I never saw the original.)

    ReplyDelete
  6. LEGIT FULLZ & TOOLS STORE

    Hello to All !

    We are offering all types of tools & Fullz on discounted price.
    If you are in search of anything regarding fullz, tools, tutorials, Hack Pack, etc
    Feel Free to contact

    ***CONTACT 24/7***
    **Telegram > @leadsupplier
    **ICQ > 752822040
    **Skype > Peeterhacks
    **Wicker me > peeterhacks

    "SSN LEADS/FULLZ AVAILABLE"
    "TOOLS & TUTORIALS AVAILABLE FOR HACKING, SPAMMING,
    CARDING, CASHOUT, CLONING, SCRIPTING ETC"

    **************************************
    "Fresh Spammed SSN Fullz info included"
    >>SSN FULLZ with complete info
    >>CC With CVV (vbv & non vbv) Fullz USA
    >>FULLZ FOR SBA, PUA & TAX RETURN FILLING
    >>USA I.D Photos Front & Back
    >>High Credit Score fullz (700+ Scores)
    >>DL number, Employee Details, Bank Details Included
    >>Complete Premium Info with Relative Info

    ***************************************
    COMPLETE GUIDE FOR TUTORIALS & TOOLS

    "SPAMMING" "HACKING" "CARDING" "CASH OUT"
    "KALI LINUX" "BLOCKCHAIN BLUE PRINTS" "SCRIPTING"
    "FRAUD BIBLE"

    "TOOLS & TUTORIALS LIST"
    =>Ethical Hacking Ebooks, Tools & Tutorials
    =>Bitcoin Hacking
    =>Kali Linux
    =>Fraud Bible
    =>RAT
    =>Keylogger & Keystroke Logger
    =>WhatsApp Hacking & Hacked Version of WhatsApp
    =>Facebook & Google Hacking
    =>Bitcoin Flasher
    =>SQL Injector
    =>Premium Logs (PayPal/Amazon/Coinbase/Netflix/FedEx/Banks)
    =>Bitcoin Cracker
    =>SMTP Linux Root
    =>Shell Scripting
    =>DUMPS with pins track 1 and 2 with & without pin
    =>SMTP's, Safe Socks, Rdp's brute
    =>PHP mailer
    =>SMS Sender & Email Blaster
    =>Cpanel
    =>Server I.P's & Proxies
    =>Viruses & VPN's
    =>HQ Email Combo (Gmail, Yahoo, Hotmail, MSN, AOL, etc.)

    *Serious buyers will always welcome
    *Price will be reduce in bulk order
    *Discount offers will give to serious buyers
    *Hope we do a great business together

    ===>Contact 24/7<===
    ==>Telegram > @leadsupplier
    ==>ICQ > 752822040
    ==>Skype > Peeterhacks
    ==>Wicker me > peeterhacks

    ReplyDelete